Review: Theater
`King and I' at Merriam is long on looks, short on emotion
By Julia M. Klein
INQUIRER STAFF WRITER
From its splendid mirror- and jewel-studded sets in imperial red and
gold to its glittering silk, sequined and beaded costumes, the current
touring production of The King and I seems like a fantasy of
mid-19th-century Siam.
But my real estate agent, who had the seat in front of mine at the
Merriam Theater Tuesday night, said she'd visited Thailand, and it all
looked quite authentic.
My theater companion, on the other hand, said he couldn't quite handle
the idea of a king with hair.
This King and I, which runs through Sunday and stars Hayley
Mills as the English schoolteacher Anna Leonowens, elicits admiration
for its Tony Award-winning sets and costumes, but not much emotional
involvement.
Strong performances in featured roles -- especially the
operatic-voiced Helen Yu as Lady Thiang and novice Timothy Ford Murphy
as Lun Tha -- didn't quite atone for the lack of chemistry between
Mills and Mel Duane Gionson's comically adept but insufficiently fierce
King of Siam. Gionson was subbing for Vee Talmadge.
Rodgers and Hammerstein's classic 1951 musical about Anna and the king
-- based on a true story and Margaret Landon's 1944 novel -- plays with
a series of contrasts: between barbarism and civilization, slavery and
freedom, modernity and tradition. Anna embodies the civilizing influence
of Western (in this case, British) culture on a king who is caught
between past and present.
There's no ambiguity in the show's take on history, which associates
modernity with progress. But, in addition to lovely songs, there are
some exceedingly well-written scenes between Anna and the king, which
depict a developing attraction and mutual need. These culminate in the
polka duet "Shall We Dance?" where emotion finds pure expression in
movement. But even this climactic courtship scene -- though
well-directed by Christopher Renshaw -- doesn't quite seal the bond
between this odd couple.
Mills is a softer Anna than Deborah Kerr's film version, likable but
without much acerbity or brio. It doesn't help that her singing is
marginal at best; songs as straightforward as "Getting to Know You" and
"I Whistle a Happy Tune" demand a more confident delivery.
Gionson's king may not erase the memory of Yul Brynner, but he, too, is
likable and gets his laughs. What his performance lacks is some larger,
more tragic dimension -- as well as a chemistry with his costar.
Without emotional conviction at its core, the show is dominated by its
tendencies toward melodrama -- and, of course, spectacle.
But there are still marvelous moments to savor. Yu has extraordinary
presence as Lady Thiang, the head wife in the king's harem, and her
rendition of "Something Wonderful" is indeed that. Luzviminda Lor as
Tuptim and Murphy as Lun Tha -- the doomed young lovers -- get the
show's most gorgeous melodies, and their duets are transportingly
romantic.
And then there are the children. In their processional before the king
and throughout the nearly three-hour show, they are alternately cute,
endearing and very funny.
|